Next stop on our Europe ’72 listening tour brings us to Rheinhalle, Düsseldorf, in West Germany on April 24, 1972. Not only was this show released in full with the rest of of the shows on the Europe ’72 complete recordings, but the show had also been released prior to this back in 2004, labeled as Rockin’ the Rhein with the Grateful Dead. This is quite the stellar show so lets get right into it!
The set list for the Dead rockin’ at Rheinhalle in Düsseldorf tonight is as follows:
Set 1: Truckin’, Tennessee Jed, Chinatown Shuffle, Black-Throated Wind, China Cat Sunflower > I Know You Rider, Mr. Charlie, Beat It On Down The Line, Loser, Playin’ In The Band, Next Time You See Me, Me And Bobby McGee, Good Lovin’, Casey Jones
Set 2: Dark Star > Me & My Uncle > Dark Star > Wharf Rat > Sugar Magnolia
Set 3: He’s Gone, It Hurts Me Too, El Paso, Not Fade Away > Goin’ Down The Road Feelin’ Bad > Not Fade Away, E: One More Saturday Night
The Dead kick off this show with Truckin’, nothing mind-blowing going on in this one, but it is still nonetheless an exciting pick to open the show. Black-Throated Wind and the China Cat Sunflower > I Know You Rider are some real standout tunes in the beginning of the first set. first off Kieth’s work on Black-Throated Wind is phenomenal and really compliments what the rest of the band has going on. China Cat > Rider is exceptional too, showcasing some flavor of what to expect in later versions. The other songs that deserve some attention in the first set would be Playing In The Band and Good Lovin’, with an honorable mention to Next Time You See Me. This Playin’ is dizzy and spaced out, it not only opens up the door for the guitars to wander but it also leaves the rest of the band to branch out and explore too. Good Lovin’ in this set is further another fine selection too, it rolls in smooth and thick with Phil’s excellent bass work right into the enthralling as always Pigpen vocals, the backing vocals from Phil for this one however can sound bit strained at times. Despite this very minor nitpicking I think this is a real strong version, Pigpen’s on fire, the rest of the band is on fire, and the jams are tight and energetic.
For the second set the Dead begin a journey with Dark Star, two parts to this one it is most certainly a trip. The first part is slow, airy, and loose for the first little bit, however it speeds up as the song goes on, gradually getting faster, still resonating with that same aimless fluidity until it melds into Me and My Uncle. After Me and My Uncle the Dead take it back to Dark Star to take it even further than before, the wandering of guitars leaves Keith to experiment and make his presence known, he sounds great and really delivers on this second part and Me and My Uncle. After this the Dead take to finish off this set with Wharf Rat and Sugar Magnolia.
The third set opens with He’s Gone, it’s apparent that the Dead are still working on the arrangement of this song but they still do get along alright for this song. On El Paso Bob sounds a bit rough with the vocals, but can you blame him after he belts out a show-stopping Sunshine Daydream? The last few songs, NFA > GDTRFB > NFA are of course show highlights as well, it can be easy to forget about this one after the magnificent second set, but this selection is still nonetheless a good one, strong and tight, it more often than not delivers!
Make sure to listen to the Grateful Dead rockin’ at the Rhein on April 24, 1972 here: https://archive.org/details/gd72-04-24.sbd-aud.cotsman.16332.sbeok.shnf